In such a dystopia-mad culture, you’d think movies by now would have run through every possible iteration, tapped dry every fresh idea. And yet, watching Peacekeepers – the Hunger Games franchise’s version of Stormtroopers – set up wayfinding signs to direct preteen girls where to stand to find out if they’ll be forced into an arena to compete in televised blood sport, I thought to myself with real pleasure, “Well, that’s a new one.”
The bureaucracy of evil, the mining of child murder for entertainment, the exploitation of fear as the mind killer (whoops, wrong franchise): These are the grim, knotty ideas animating the Hunger Games series, which began as a three-book YA series by Suzanne Collins, was adapted into a four–part film series starring Jennifer Lawrence, and has since rooted around in narrative cul-de-sacs via prequels. The first prequel, 2023’s The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, studied the inner tickings of the future President Snow, a conflicted young man who would grow into the embodiment of pure evil. With this second prequel, which dramatizes Haymitch Abernathy’s time in the arena, we’re firmly back in hero territory.
Australian actor Joseph Zada is credibly cast as the 16-year-old Haymitch, a character Woody Harrelson played in the original series as an embittered, fortysomething drunk. Initially fresh-faced, sober-minded, and sweet on Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), this Haymitch is sold as “the rascal” once he arrives in the Capitol to fight in the kill-or-be-killed 50th Hunger Games. As Haymitch leans into that persona, Zada dials up the drawling mimicry of Harrelson; the vocal similarity is uncanny. Here and elsewhere, casting directors Dylan Jury and Debra Zane have effectively zeroed in on plausible younger versions of characters we’d see again in the 25-years-in-the-future original series: Jesse Plemons in a more earnestly revolutionary take on Philip Seymour Hoffman’s double agent Plutarch Heavensbee; Elle Fanning, sweetly trilling as Elizabeth Banks’ peppy stylist Effie Trinket; Kieran Culkin, funny and slick in a nastier spin on Stanley Tucci’s TV host Caesar Flickerman. (Ralph Fiennes seemed like the most inspired casting of all to play the bridge to Donald Sutherland’s President Snow, but his Snow is restrained to the point of limpness in a definitional paycheck gig.)
Newer characters suffer without all that built-in backstory. Capitol stooge Glenn Close is the most broad villain the series has seen; she largely exists to be the stretched-tight face of elitism and excess, but given how commonplace her kind of nightmare plastic surgery has become in our own here and now, what used to be a pointed commentary has inevitably dulled. Peak’s Lenore is lovely, but has little to do but reiterate the film’s thesis that no future is inevitable (all evidence to the contrary). As a prickly tribute from Haymitch’s District 12, Mckenna Grace can’t sell surly with the same conviction as a Jennifer Lawrence or Jena Malone, but she’s a solid enough anchor in a film littered with disposable bodies.
Greater detail has been lavished on the overall aesthetic – this one’s serving 1970s, for a tasty jumble of psychedelia and Logan’s Run – and the game arena landscape. The latter presents a comically inverted Disney-like forest, all flittering butterflies and Technicolor flowers and floppy-eared rabbits … only the butterflies will sting you, the pollen will choke you, and the bunnies are bleeding from the eyes. Though the action set pieces aren’t as memorable as in films past, they’re breathtakingly assembled for maximum horror (mind the PG-13 rating) and racing heart rate.
And ultimately, isn’t that the draw here? Isn’t that the line drawn directly between us and the Panem audience? We thrill at the same things: the pomp and circumstance of the tribute parade (by now, James Newton Howard’s musical cues are as familiar as John Williams’ Olympics fanfare) and the gruesome terrors inside the arena. The most interesting thing about Sunrise on the Reaping is how it, like its predecessors, puts us in cahoots with the Capitol. We too are complicit in enjoying the spectacle.
Interrogating that, alas, is not where this movie is headed. Inheriting structural challenges from the novel, screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie snuffle the ground for some possible way to send the audience out on a not-bummer note. We get bland speeches about resistance and playing the long game, we get a wincing coda that trots out the original actors. We get a movie afraid of its own shadow – but the shadows are what most compel us.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping2026, PG-13, 158 min. Directed by Francis Lawrence. Starring Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace, Maya Hawke, Whitney Peak, Kelvin Harrison Jr.
⭐⭐⭐
Rating: 2.5 out of 5.The post The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Review: Once More, With Bleeding appeared first on The Austin Chronicle.
All Rights Reserved. Copyright , Central Coast Communications, Inc.